Caroline Weldon, doomed savior of Sitting Bull
Most people have never heard of Caroline Weldon, but she might be the most tragic white ally in American history. This Brooklyn mother gave up everything to help Sitting Bull fight land seizures in 1889.
She became his secretary and closest advisor until the Ghost Dance tore them apart. Her son died, Sitting Bull was killed, and she returned home broken. Here’s what went wrong.
Helping the Sioux Through Sitting Bull
Susanna Karolina Faesch had nothing left to lose by 1889.
The Swiss-born woman endured a bad marriage in Brooklyn, divorce, and abandonment by her married lover who left her with son Christie.
Her mother’s death in 1887 brought an inheritance and freedom to pursue a new obsession. She changed her name to Caroline Weldon, joined the National Indian Defense Association, and began writing letters to Sitting Bull.
The Dawes Act was breaking up tribal lands, but this Lakota chief was fighting back. Weldon offered her help against a government trying to destroy his people.
Nobody Invited Her To Standing Rock
Weldon stepped off the train in June 1889 with twelve-year-old Christie, walking onto Standing Rock Reservation without invitation.
She found Sitting Bull recovering from near-fatal pneumonia, his followers gathered around their weakened leader.
Word spread quickly about the uninvited white woman. The Bismarck Weekly Tribune mocked her as a “New Jersey Widow Falls Victim to Sitting Bull’s Charms.”
Local papers called her “Sitting Bull’s white squaw” while Indian Agent James McLaughlin watched this unwelcome arrival with growing alarm.
Sitting Bull Let Her Become His Voice
As Sitting Bull recovered, Weldon moved into his compound and became his secretary, interpreter, and advocate.
She spent her inheritance buying food and supplies for his extended family while organizing resistance to the Sioux Bill that threatened millions more reservation acres.
Weldon handled correspondence, translated legal documents, and painted four portraits of the chief during evening hours.
The Lakota gave her a name that captured her courage: “Woman Walking Ahead.” For the first time in years, she had found purpose.
McLaughlin Turned Newspapers Against Her
The Indian Agent had spent years trying to break Sitting Bull’s influence, and now this white woman was strengthening it.
McLaughlin fed stories to reporters about an improper relationship between Weldon and the chief. National newspapers picked up the tales, portraying her as a delusional spinster bewitched by a savage.
The coverage served McLaughlin perfectly, turning white public opinion against both Weldon and Sitting Bull while justifying future action.
Every article made her more hated, but she refused to leave.
Ghost Dancers Brought New Hope And Danger
Summer 1890 brought the Ghost Dance movement to Standing Rock.
Paiute prophet Wovoka promised that circular dancing would resurrect the dead and drive white settlers from Indian lands.
The movement offered hope to tribes facing extinction, and Sitting Bull allowed dancers to gather at his camp. McLaughlin saw his opportunity.
He could now claim the chief was leading a dangerous uprising that threatened white settlers across the territory, giving him the excuse he needed for decisive action.
She Begged Him To Stop The Dancing
Weldon watched the Ghost Dance gatherings with growing fear. She understood how government officials thought and knew they would view this as rebellion.
She warned Sitting Bull that the ceremonies gave McLaughlin exactly the pretext he needed to bring in troops and destroy the Sioux Nation.
The chief listened but rejected her advice, saying his people needed hope.
Their close partnership began fracturing as Weldon publicly opposed the dance, creating a rift with the man she had traveled so far to protect.
Christie Got Sick When Tensions Peaked
November brought Christie’s serious illness and an impossible choice for his mother.
The boy needed medical care unavailable at Standing Rock, but leaving meant abandoning Sitting Bull during the most dangerous period of his life.
Weldon could see military forces building around the reservation and knew McLaughlin was planning something terrible.
Yet Christie was dying, and she was his mother first. With a breaking heart, she packed their belongings and left the man she had crossed the continent to save.
Her Son Died Before Reaching Safety
The riverboat journey to Kansas City became a nightmare when Christie died near Pierre, South Dakota, on November 19, 1890.
Caroline Weldon had sacrificed everything, and now both her son and her mission were lost. She continued to her nephew’s home carrying her dead child, the inheritance that funded her work now spent.
The boy who had shared her Plains adventure was gone, and somewhere behind her, the danger she had warned about was closing in on Sitting Bull.
Police Came For Him At Dawn
At daybreak on December 15, 1890, thirty-nine Indian policemen surrounded Sitting Bull’s cabin on the Grand River.
Lieutenant Bull Head knocked with arrest orders from McLaughlin, who had finally received permission to eliminate his greatest obstacle.
Sitting Bull dressed calmly and stepped outside, but his wives began wailing and a crowd gathered in the gray morning light.
When Catch-the-Bear shot the wounded Bull Head, the officer fired into Sitting Bull’s chest while Red Tomahawk’s bullet to the head killed him instantly.
They Destroyed Her Painting Too
One of Weldon’s portraits hung in Sitting Bull’s cabin as gunfire erupted around it.
After fourteen people lay dead and the shooting stopped, an Indian policeman whose brother had died smashed the painting with his rifle butt, tearing the canvas.
U.S. Cavalry Lieutenant Matthew Steele rescued the damaged artwork before complete destruction, later purchasing it from Sitting Bull’s widows for two dollars.
The portrait became another casualty that claimed the friendship it represented.
She Came Home To Nothing
The Wounded Knee Massacre followed two weeks later, with soldiers killing nearly three hundred Lakota. Weldon learned of both tragedies from Kansas City, watching her worst fears come true.
She eventually returned to Brooklyn, but white society shunned the woman who had lived among Indians and served as Sitting Bull’s secretary.
She spent her final decades in poverty and isolation until March 15, 1921, when she died alone from burns in an apartment fire, her sacrifice forgotten by history.
Visiting The Sitting Bull Memorial
The memorial marks where Sitting Bull’s remains were reburied in 1953 after his family moved them from Fort Yates, North Dakota.
You’ll find the six-foot granite bust carved by Korczak Ziolkowski (who also created Crazy Horse Memorial) about seven miles southwest of Mobridge, South Dakota, on Highway 1806 overlooking the Missouri River.
The site remains free and uncommercial out of respect for Sitting Bull’s descendants. The nearby Sakakawea Monument commemorates the Lewis and Clark guide.
No exhibits connect directly to Caroline Weldon, but the actual Grand River site where Sitting Bull lived and died with Weldon’s paintings is about 40 miles away near Little Eagle on Standing Rock Reservation, though no public access or markers exist there.
This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.
Read more from this brand:
The post This Swiss immigrant became Sitting Bull’s advocate and got smeared as his mistress by the government appeared first on When In Your State.