Chief Lawyer’s Betrayal That Destroyed the Nez Perce
The Nez Perce National Historical Park preserves the site where gold fever destroyed a nation in 1863. When miners found gold on tribal lands in 1860, the government didn’t remove the trespassers.
Instead, they forced a new treaty. Chief Lawyer signed away 90% of Nez Perce homeland, but many chiefs refused.
Chief Joseph tore up his old treaty and rode away angry. The Nez Perce split into “treaty” and “non-treaty” factions, setting up the tragic 1877 war.
The Spalding Visitor Center tells this story of betrayal that changed everything.
Gold Rush Sparked a Crisis on Nez Perce Land
Gold showed up near Pierce, Idaho in 1860, right on the Nez Perce reservation set up by the 1855 treaty. About 5,000 miners broke the law and rushed onto tribal lands, setting up Lewiston for supplies.
The U. S. government didn’t kick out these trespassers, even though the treaty said they had to remove white people who didn’t belong.
These miners made things worse by plowing up the sacred camas prairies that the Nez Perce needed for food.
The Government Chose a New Treaty Over Enforcing the Old One
By 1863, the number of miners breaking the law on Nez Perce lands grew to over 15,000. Instead of making these trespassers leave, the government called for a new treaty meeting at Lapwai in May 1863.
Calvin Hale, Charles Hutchins, and S. D. Howe came as American officials. Their plan wasn’t to fix the problem but to make the illegal mining camps legal by cutting the reservation by 90%.
Lawyer Became the Government’s Handpicked “Head Chief”
Chief Lawyer was the son of Twisted Hair who had welcomed Lewis and Clark years earlier. The government picked him as their “head chief” to deal with.
This went against Nez Perce ways, where bands always acted on their own with no single leader for everyone.
The 56 separate band leaders usually made choices for their own people, but American officials wanted just one person to talk to.
Non-Treaty Chiefs Showed Up Ready to Fight Back
The chiefs who opposed the new treaty, including Joseph, White Bird, and Eagle From The Light, arrived on June 3rd. Thunder Eyes joined them even though his Lapwai Valley lands wouldn’t be affected by the new boundaries.
These anti-treaty leaders spoke for about two-thirds of all Nez Perce people.
The mood got tense when government officials admitted they hadn’t kept their promises from the 1855 treaty.
A Powerful Speech Backed the Government Into a Corner
Lawyer gave a moving speech listing all the times the Nez Perce had helped Americans since Lewis and Clark first came through their lands.
He asked for payment for the ferries and towns that white settlers had built without permission on Nez Perce land. He stood firm that the Nez Perce couldn’t sell any more of their family lands.
The government men couldn’t change his mind and took a six-day break from talks.
The Devastating Terms Cut Deep Into Tribal Territory
The new treaty would shrink the reservation from 7. 5 million acres to just 750,000 acres in Idaho Territory.
The Wallowa Valley, Salmon River country, and most family lands would open up for white people to settle. The government wanted to split what was left into 20-acre lots for farming “just as whites do.”
Only Lawyer’s followers would keep their homes since their lands stayed inside the new reservation lines.
Thunder Eyes Split the Nation With Emotional Words
The treaty and non-treaty groups talked all night, speaking with “dignity and warmth” about what to do. Thunder Eyes, speaking for the chiefs against Lawyer, announced that “the Nez Perce nation dissolved.”
The two groups agreed to part as “friends, but a distinct people,” creating treaty and non-treaty groups. This marked the first time in their history that the Nez Perce nation had ever been divided.
Chief Joseph Tore Up His Treaty in Disgust
Old Joseph (Chief Joseph’s father) got so angry he tore up his copy of the 1855 treaty right in front of the officials. He also ripped up his Gospel of Matthew that missionary Henry Spalding had given him years before.
He rode home in disgust, refusing to join any more treaty talks.
Back in the Wallowa Valley, he marked the land with poles saying his people would never give up the ground where their ancestors were buried.
Fifty-One Signatures Gave Away Five Million Acres
On June 9, 1863, Chief Lawyer and 51 headmen signed away over 5 million acres of Nez Perce land. Only those living within the planned new boundaries took part in the signing.
The non-treaty chiefs including Joseph, White Bird, and others refused to sign the paper.
The government acted as if all Nez Perce had to follow this treaty, even though about two-thirds of the tribe opposed it.
Old Joseph Refused to Leave His Homeland
Old Joseph went back to the Wallowa Valley and refused to move his band to the Idaho reservation. He stayed in his family homeland until he died in 1871, never accepting the 1863 treaty as real.
Before his death, he told his son Young Joseph to “never sell the bones of your father and mother. ” His stubborn stand kept the Wallowa band free from reservation life for 14 years after the treaty was signed.
The “Steal Treaty” Led to War Fourteen Years Later
This 1863 agreement, known as the “Steal Treaty,” created a permanent split between treaty and non-treaty Nez Perce groups.
The government’s failure to honor its promises and its decision to reward illegal occupation planted the seeds for future conflict.
Non-treaty bands kept living on their ancestral lands while treaty bands moved to the reservation. This unresolved division eventually exploded into the brutal Nez Perce War of 1877.
Visiting Nez Perce National Historical Park
You can explore the tragic story of the 1863 Treaty at Nez Perce National Historical Park on US Highway 95 in Lapwai, Idaho. All 38 sites are free to visit.
The museum holds 150,000 artifacts from the mid-1800s, including the returned Spalding-Allen Collection in the Wetxuuwíitin exhibit. Ask to watch the 20-minute film about Nez Perce history.
You’ll also see original Spalding Mission buildings and Indian Agency structures.
This article was created with AI assistance and human editing.
Read more from this brand:
The post The chief who signed away 90% of Nez Perce territory to illegal gold miners and sparked a war appeared first on When In Your State.